The International Journal of Pharmaceutical Research and Medical Sciences (IJPRMS) recognizes that Artificial Intelligence (AI), Generative Artificial Intelligence (Generative AI), and Large Language Models (LLMs) can assist researchers, authors, reviewers, and editors in various aspects of scholarly communication. The journal permits responsible and transparent use of AI-assisted technologies while maintaining the principles of research integrity, authorship, originality, transparency, confidentiality, and accountability.
This policy applies to the use of AI and Generative AI tools in manuscript preparation, research activities, data analysis, image generation or modification, peer review, editorial work, and other stages of the publication process.
1. General Principles
IJPRMS permits the responsible use of AI-assisted technologies provided that such use does not compromise the originality, accuracy, integrity, confidentiality, or ethical standards of scholarly work.
Authors, reviewers, editors, and other contributors remain fully responsible for the content and decisions associated with their work. AI tools cannot assume responsibility for the accuracy, integrity, originality, or ethical conduct of a manuscript and therefore cannot be considered authors or co-authors.
AI-generated or AI-assisted content must be carefully reviewed and verified by humans because AI systems may produce inaccurate, incomplete, biased, fabricated, or misleading information.
2. Use of AI by Authors
Authors may use AI-assisted technologies for limited and appropriate purposes, such as:
Language improvement, grammar correction, spelling, and readability.
Assistance with manuscript organization or formatting.
Assistance with brainstorming or developing ideas.
Translation or language-related assistance.
Assistance with coding or programming, provided that the resulting code and outputs are independently verified.
Assistance with data analysis, where the use of the AI system is scientifically appropriate, transparently reported, and independently validated.
The use of AI must not replace the authors' intellectual contribution, scientific judgment, responsibility, or accountability for the research.
Authors remain responsible for:
The accuracy and integrity of all submitted information.
Verification of AI-generated statements, references, calculations, and interpretations.
Ensuring that appropriate sources are cited.
Ensuring that the manuscript does not contain plagiarism or unattributed material.
Obtaining necessary permissions for copyrighted or third-party material.
Ensuring that AI-generated content does not introduce fabricated data, unsupported claims, or misleading conclusions.
3. Disclosure of AI Use
Authors must disclose the use of AI-assisted technologies when AI has contributed substantively to the preparation, analysis, generation, or presentation of the manuscript.
The disclosure should identify:
The name of the AI tool or technology used.
The purpose for which it was used.
The part of the manuscript, research, analysis, or figures in which it was used.
Where appropriate, the version or date of the AI tool.
For example:
AI Use Disclosure: During the preparation of this manuscript, the authors used [name of AI tool] for [describe purpose, e.g., language editing and grammar improvement]. The authors reviewed and verified all AI-assisted content and take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and final content of the manuscript.
If AI was used for data analysis, research methodology, coding, figure generation, or other substantive research activities, the authors should provide appropriate details in the Methods, Acknowledgments, or another relevant section of the manuscript.
Current ICMJE guidance recommends that authors disclose AI-assisted technologies used in the production of submitted work and explain how they were used.
4. AI Cannot Be an Author or Co-Author
AI systems, chatbots, Generative AI tools, and LLMs must not be listed as authors or co-authors of manuscripts submitted to IJPRMS.
Authorship requires human responsibility for the work, including responsibility for its accuracy, integrity, originality, and ethical compliance. AI systems cannot fulfill these responsibilities.
Authors should not:
List ChatGPT or another AI system as an author or co-author.
Attribute authorship to an AI system.
Present AI-generated content as the independent intellectual contribution of a named human author without appropriate disclosure.
Use AI-generated material to falsely represent the originality or authorship of scholarly work.
This principle is consistent with current ICMJE recommendations.
5. AI-Generated Text and Manuscript Content
The use of Generative AI to produce substantial portions of a manuscript must be disclosed.
Authors must critically evaluate and revise any AI-assisted text before submission. AI-generated text must not be accepted without human verification.
Authors are responsible for ensuring that:
Statements are factually correct.
Scientific interpretations are supported by evidence.
References actually exist and accurately support the cited claims.
No fabricated citations or sources are included.
No copyrighted or unattributed material has been improperly reproduced.
The final manuscript accurately represents the authors' research and conclusions.
AI-generated text should not be used to fabricate scientific observations, experimental findings, clinical information, or research conclusions.
6. AI-Generated or AI-Assisted Images
AI-generated or AI-assisted images, illustrations, graphical abstracts, diagrams, or other visual materials must comply with the journal's requirements for scientific integrity and image presentation.
Authors must disclose the use of AI when it has been used to generate, substantially modify, or manipulate an image.
AI must not be used to:
Fabricate experimental results or scientific evidence.
Add, remove, or alter research findings in a misleading manner.
Manipulate clinical, microscopic, radiographic, electrophoretic, photographic, or other scientific images in a way that changes their interpretation.
Create images that falsely represent experimental observations.
Misrepresent an AI-generated illustration as an actual experimental result.
Where AI-assisted image generation or modification has been used, authors should describe the tool and the nature of the modification in the appropriate section of the manuscript.
7. AI and Research Data
AI tools may be used for research-related data processing or analysis only when scientifically appropriate and when their use is fully disclosed.
Authors must independently verify AI-assisted analyses and remain responsible for the accuracy of the resulting data and conclusions.
AI must not be used to:
Generate fabricated experimental data.
Invent participants, observations, measurements, or clinical outcomes.
Alter or manipulate research data.
Create false statistical results.
Select or modify data solely to produce a desired conclusion.
Generate misleading tables or figures presented as actual research findings.
Any intentional use of AI to fabricate, manipulate, or misrepresent research data may be considered research misconduct or publication misconduct and may result in appropriate editorial action.
8. AI and References
Authors are responsible for verifying every reference included in a manuscript.
AI-generated references must not be accepted without independent verification.
Authors must ensure that:
Every cited reference is genuine.
The cited article actually supports the statement for which it is cited.
Bibliographic information is accurate.
Appropriate original sources are cited where available.
AI-generated material should not be used as a substitute for appropriate primary scientific literature.
9. AI Use by Peer Reviewers
Peer reviewers must protect the confidentiality of manuscripts submitted to IJPRMS.
Reviewers must not upload, paste, or otherwise transfer confidential manuscript content, figures, data, reviewer reports, or unpublished information into publicly accessible or third-party AI systems unless such use has been explicitly permitted by the journal and confidentiality can be assured.
Reviewers must not use AI tools to independently generate or submit a peer review without appropriate authorization.
If AI is permitted for assistance during peer review, reviewers remain responsible for:
Maintaining manuscript confidentiality.
Verifying the accuracy of any AI-assisted output.
Providing an independent and objective evaluation.
Disclosing their use of AI to the editorial office when required.
Current ICMJE guidance emphasizes that manuscript confidentiality may prohibit uploading submitted manuscripts to AI systems where confidentiality cannot be assured.
10. AI Use by Editors and Editorial Staff
Editors and editorial staff may use AI-assisted technologies only in ways that are consistent with confidentiality, publication ethics, and the journal's editorial responsibilities.
Editors and editorial staff must not upload confidential manuscripts or unpublished material into AI systems where confidentiality cannot be adequately protected.
Where AI is used for editorial or production purposes, the editorial team remains responsible for verifying the accuracy, appropriateness, and integrity of the resulting content.
Editors must not allow AI-generated recommendations or outputs to replace independent editorial judgment.
11. Confidentiality and Protection of Unpublished Work
Manuscripts submitted to IJPRMS are confidential scholarly documents.
Authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff must protect unpublished manuscripts and associated information from unauthorized disclosure.
The use of AI systems that retain, process, or reuse submitted manuscript content may create confidentiality, privacy, intellectual property, or data-security concerns. Therefore, confidential manuscript information must not be entered into AI systems unless the journal has expressly permitted such use and adequate confidentiality safeguards are in place.
12. Plagiarism, Copyright, and Intellectual Property
Authors remain responsible for ensuring that AI-assisted content does not infringe copyright, intellectual property rights, privacy rights, or other legal rights.
The use of AI does not exempt authors from the journal's plagiarism and originality requirements.
Authors must:
Properly attribute sources.
Obtain permission where required.
Avoid reproducing copyrighted material without authorization.
Verify AI-generated quotations and references.
Ensure that the submitted work represents an original and appropriately attributed scholarly contribution.
AI-generated content must not be used as a means of concealing plagiarism or unauthorized reproduction of another person's work.
13. Undisclosed or Misleading Use of AI
Failure to disclose substantive AI use, when disclosure is required under this policy, may lead to editorial inquiry.
Depending on the circumstances, undisclosed or misleading use of AI may result in:
A request for clarification or disclosure.
Correction of the published article.
Reassessment of the manuscript.
Rejection or withdrawal of the manuscript.
Retraction of a published article.
Notification of the authors' institution or other appropriate authority where serious misconduct is suspected.
ICMJE notes that nondisclosure of AI use may require corrective action and, in some circumstances, may be considered misconduct.
14. Responsibility of Authors
The corresponding author and all listed authors are responsible for ensuring compliance with this policy.
By submitting a manuscript to IJPRMS, authors confirm that:
All authors have reviewed and approved the submitted manuscript.
Any required use of AI-assisted technologies has been disclosed.
AI has not been listed as an author or co-author.
AI-generated information has been appropriately verified.
The manuscript contains no intentionally fabricated data, references, images, or scientific claims.
The authors accept full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and ethical compliance of the submitted work.
15. Policy Updates
IJPRMS may periodically revise this policy to reflect developments in artificial intelligence, research practices, publication ethics, copyright requirements, data protection, and recommendations from recognized organizations.
Authors, reviewers, editors, and editorial staff are expected to comply with the version of the policy applicable at the time of their participation in the publication process.
Suggested AI Disclosure Statement for Authors
Declaration of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies: The authors declare that [name of AI tool] was used during the preparation of this manuscript for [describe purpose]. All AI-assisted content was critically reviewed, verified, and edited by the authors. The authors take full responsibility for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and final content of the manuscript.
No AI Use Statement
Declaration of Generative AI and AI-Assisted Technologies: The authors declare that no Generative AI or AI-assisted technologies were used in the preparation, analysis, or generation of this manuscript, except for routine software functions that do not generate substantive scholarly content.